SubscribeLatest 5 articles from heartwire
- Interventional cardiologist Donald Baim dies
Nov 06, 2009 18:22 EDT - Latest European and US STEMI guidelines compared and contrasted
Nov 06, 2009 17:15 EDT - Enrollment halts in randomized trial of CPR for out-of-hospital arrest
Nov 06, 2009 16:00 EDT - Medicaid access to smoking cessation falls short
Nov 05, 2009 17:30 EDT - Serum phosphorous, kidney function predict CAC
Nov 05, 2009 17:00 EDT
Episode #2: Dissecting "the cost conundrum": McAllen, Gawande, Obama, and healthcare reform in the US
Please note that the audio will stop and restart at the beginning of the file when submitting a comment.
Veuillez notez que le fichier audio s’arrête et recommence au début lorsqu’un commentaire est publié.
DOWNLOAD
Download this episode in your preferred format:
The media is buzzing with discussions of Dr Atul Gawande's article in the New Yorker magazine, which looks at the astounding healthcare costs in the town of McAllen, TX. How did this "outlier" capture the attention of the nation and fuel the debate for healthcare reform? Is the debate fair and balanced or rather tainted by journalistic hyperbole?
Previous postsBillets précédents
Episode #4: Why is medicine resistant to change?
No commentsAucun commentaire |
Posted Oct 29, 2009
at 01:30 PM, EDT by Steven Publié le 10.29.2009 à 13h30 par Steven
at 01:30 PM, EDT by Steven Publié le 10.29.2009 à 13h30 par Steven
Episode #3: Percutaneous aortic-valve procedures
No commentsAucun commentaire |
Posted Jul 29, 2009
at 11:30 AM, EDT by Steven Publié le 07.29.2009 à 11h30 par Steven
at 11:30 AM, EDT by Steven Publié le 07.29.2009 à 11h30 par Steven
Episode #1: Revascularization trials: Bypass vs PCI
3 comments3 commentaires |
Posted May 04, 2009
at 10:40 AM, EDT by Steven Publié le 05.04.2009 à 10h40 par Steven
at 10:40 AM, EDT by Steven Publié le 05.04.2009 à 10h40 par Steven
Also from theheart.org
About the Click and Rub Show
theheart.org brings you a freewheeling and unconventional exchange on the latest cardiology news and events through the eyes of thought leaders Drs Eric Topol and Paul Teirstein from Scripps Translational Research Institute.
We value the diverse opinions of our readership (that includes you!) -- share your thoughts by writing them in the comments box at left and stay tuned for new shows, posted on a monthly basis.
We value the diverse opinions of our readership (that includes you!) -- share your thoughts by writing them in the comments box at left and stay tuned for new shows, posted on a monthly basis.
CommentsCommentaires
It is impossible to deny a political agenda in Gawande's article considering its tone and timing of release. If the cost of medical care in McAllen is indeed one of the highest in the nation is not because of overutilization of resources but instead because of having to take care of a sicker and older population.
He implies that overutilization is done for financial gain because "doctors have an echo machine, nuclear medicine and even CTA in their offices". Self referral is not a sin as long as it is used judiciously.
There are specific aspects that must be controlled: overspending in home health is one of them. Electronic medical records will help avoid redundancy in medical tests.
As Dr. Terstein rightfully states, if a lay person reads this paper the obvious conclusion will be that all doctors in McAllen are crooks. As in any other medical society we have had our share of bad apples that have been appropriately fined, marginalized, suspended or even incarcerated because of actions started by their own peers.
I take offense by Dr. Topol's comments about seeking medical care in McAllen. According to US & News Report and Thompson data, Doctors Hospital at Renaissance in McAllen was considered among the five best hospital for cardiovascular care in Texas.
Sometimes I jockingly tell my students that for some people their only role in life may be to serve as a bad example. Please do not use us in McAllen as such in order to advance your political agenda.
Just about all procedural based physicians require a hospital affiliation in order to utilize hospital facilities and pick up a patient base.
A system of reimbursement by third parties which break procedures down into professional, technical and global and in which the smallest reimbursement is for the professional component is a problem.
Motivation is for the physician to acquire equipment which will allow global billing. The physican then becomes a direct competitor with his/her hospital.
The hospital must maintain equipment for inpatients. The net result is an oversupply of spect cameras, echo machines, x-ray, etc. While making GE, Phillips, Siemens, Toshiba happy, the system leads even the most dedicated evidence based follower into temptation. Net result: huge costs.
There are two ways to correct this problem:
1) Salaried providers who work for and utilize hospital equipment. With no bonuses given for referral of patient volume.
2) Reduction in reimbursement by CMS and insurances to make equipment purchase economically challanging. This is being promulgated for instance in echo.
One spin off that might be positive.........if we ever do drift towards the Canadian system of healthcare, there should be a surplus of equipment which would cut down waiting tmes.